🎯 Quick Overview
Trailer
- Director: Nathan Hope
- Genre: Crime, Drama, Mystery, Thriller
- Release year: 2009
- Runtime (length): 1h 46min
- IMDb rating: 5.3/10 (3.6K votes)
- Rotten Tomatoes: N/A
😅 Plot Summary – Badly Explained
Teen girl tries to escape her small town by internet-dating randos, disappears, forcing her best friend to play detective because apparently, local cops are too busy being generally creepy.
🍿 Elsewhere: Detailed Plot Synopsis
Friendship in a Small Town
Sarah and Jillian are best friends navigating life in the seemingly quiet small town of Goshen, Indiana. Despite their close bond, they have vastly different personalities: Sarah is studious and reserved, while Jillian is rebellious and yearns to escape. Jillian reveals her plan to leave town by meeting men online, hoping one will take her away. This decision creates tension between the friends as Sarah worries about the dangers involved.

Jillian’s Disappearance and Sarah’s Investigation
Soon after, Jillian vanishes, leaving Sarah only with a cryptic video message on her cell phone. The town seems indifferent to Jillian’s disappearance, perhaps due to her reputation or social standing, leaving Sarah feeling isolated in her concern. Distraught and unwilling to accept that Jillian is simply gone, Sarah decides to take matters into her own hands. She begins investigating, delving into the secrets Jillian kept and the darker side of their seemingly innocent town.

Uncovering Dark Secrets
Sarah enlists the help of Jasper, a computer-savvy friend who secretly cares for her. Together, they use Jillian’s online activity and phone records as starting points, piecing together her final days and encounters. Their search uncovers unsettling information about Goshen’s hidden underbelly, including potential ties to corrupt local police, disgruntled former boyfriends, and echoes of past unsolved disappearances, hinting at a larger, disturbing pattern.

⚠️ Spoilers and Ending Explained
🎬 Cast & Characters
- Sarah (Anna Kendrick): Jillian’s responsible best friend who becomes determined to investigate her mysterious disappearance when others fail to act.
- Jillian (Tania Raymonde): Sarah’s rebellious best friend who goes missing after meeting men online in an attempt to escape her small town life.
- Jasper (Chuck Carter): The resident computer geek who assists Sarah in her investigation into Jillian’s disappearance.
- Mr. Tod (Jon Gries): The mysterious father of a colleague and the primary suspect revealed to be responsible for the abductions.
- Billy (Paul Wesley): Jillian’s aggressive jilted ex-boyfriend, presented as an initial suspect.
- Officer Berg (Jeff Daniel Phillips): A creepy local police officer who hinders Sarah’s investigation and serves as a red herring.
💬 Memorable Quotes
- Jasper: “Jeez, I don’t think I’ve gotten 500 messages my entire life!” – Jasper reacts in disbelief to the sheer number of online messages Jillian received.
- Sarah: “That’s because you don’t have boobs Jasper.” – Sarah responds humorously to Jasper’s comment about receiving far fewer messages online than Jillian.
💰Box Office
- Budget: $500,000
- Domestic Gross: N/A
- Worldwide Gross: N/A
💥 Elsewhere Reviews
Personal Review
Okay, so I watched ‘Elsewhere’ mostly because I’m a huge Anna Kendrick fan and wanted to see some of her earlier stuff. I’ve gotta say, she’s really good in it, even though the movie itself is kinda… okay? The mystery kept me watching, trying to figure out who the bad guy was, but honestly, it felt pretty obvious early on. I liked the whole small-town vibe and how secrets were hiding everywhere. It had some genuinely creepy moments that made me jump a little! But yeah, the plot had some holes, and some character reactions felt a bit unbelievable. Still, seeing young Anna do her thing was cool, and it’s a decent watch if you’re looking for a low-key thriller and don’t mind predicting the ending.
- Who would enjoy:
- “Fans of independent crime thrillers and mysteries”
- “Viewers interested in early performances from Anna Kendrick and Paul Wesley”
- “Those who enjoy small-town secrets narratives”
- “Fans of character-driven dramas with suspenseful elements”
- Content warnings ⚠:
- “Depiction of missing persons and abduction”
- “Themes of online dangers and predators”
- “Contains mature themes and unsettling situations”
- “Some scenes of tension and implied threat (minimal on-screen violence/gore reported)”
Professional Reviews
- IndieWire: “”Elsewhere” is a serviceable, if predictable, small-town thriller notable primarily for an early glimpse of Anna Kendrick’s talent. While the script falters with cliché characters and a telegraphed mystery, Kendrick brings a much-needed grounding presence. The film achieves moments of atmosphere, but ultimately feels like a stepping stone, more intriguing for its cast’s future than its own narrative.
- Film Quarterly: “Despite some visually competent moments, “Elsewhere” struggles to build genuine tension or surprise. The central mystery is frustratingly transparent, undermining the detective work of the lead characters. While the themes of online danger and small-town secrets are relevant, they’re explored superficially. Watch it for early performances, but don’t expect a compelling thriller.
- The Daily Cinephile: “This indie mystery doesn’t quite hit its stride. The premise is intriguing – a best friend searching for a missing girl in a town that wants to forget – but the execution is uneven. Pacing issues and some questionable character decisions detract from the potential suspense. Anna Kendrick is solid, showing hints of the talent to come, but she can’t elevate the material entirely.
Audience Reactions
Anna Kendrick’s early performance stands out.: Many found the movie watchable or decent, especially enjoying the lead actress.
The mystery, while predictable for some, kept others engaged.: The core premise of a friend searching for a missing person resonated with viewers.
It delivers some genuinely creepy or tense moments.: The film successfully creates a sense of dread or unease at times.
Overall Consensus: A mixed bag: predictable mystery plot but praised for early performances from its cast, particularly Anna Kendrick, and a generally watchable, if flawed, small-town thriller experience.
Awards
🛠️ Behind the Scenes
- “All close-up shots of Sarah’s hand holding her phone were filmed on a single afternoon in the library, and it was indeed Anna Kendrick’s actual hand.”
- “A notable goof involves cell phones belonging to characters missing for weeks or even years still having battery life and functioning perfectly.”
🖥️ How to Watch Elsewhere?
As a 2009 independent film, ‘Elsewhere’ may not be readily available on major subscription streaming platforms. Based on past availability and general digital distribution trends for similar titles, your best options are likely digital rental or purchase. Check platforms like Amazon Prime Video, Apple TV, Vudu, Google Play, and YouTube Movies for availability in your region. Availability can change over time.

🎥 Similar Movies
If you enjoyed Elsewhere, you might like these similar films:
- When a Stranger Calls (2006): Features a teen protagonist in peril facing a mysterious threat, similar to Sarah’s investigation putting her in danger.
- Searching (2018): Follows a parent using digital footprints and online communication to find a missing person, mirroring Sarah and Jasper’s online investigation.
- Untraceable (2008): Revolves around an FBI agent tracking a serial killer who uses the internet to livestream his murders, echoing the theme of online danger leading to real-world violence.
- Missing (2023): A standalone sequel to ‘Searching’, continuing the theme of a teenager using modern technology and the internet to find a missing parent, representing a contemporary take on the ‘digital search’ mystery.
- Brick (2005): A stylish neo-noir led by a teenage protagonist investigating a disappearance within a distinct high school and small-town subculture, appealing to fans of teen-led mysteries with unique tones.
🛒 Elsewhere Related Products
- Elsewhere (2009) Digital Download: Own or rent the mystery-thriller ‘Elsewhere’ instantly. Follow Sarah’s quest to find her missing best friend in a town full of secrets.
- Small Town Mystery: A Collection of Thriller Novels: Dive into gripping tales of secrets, disappearances, and dark pasts hidden within seemingly quiet small towns. Features multiple acclaimed authors.
- Teen Detective Board Game: The Missing Case: An interactive board game where players work together (or compete) to solve the mysterious disappearance of a teenager in a suburban town.
- Anna Kendrick: Early Career Collection (DVD/Blu-ray): A compilation featuring some of Anna Kendrick’s notable roles from her early career, showcasing her versatility before widespread fame.
🎧 Soundtrack
Elsewhere features a captivating soundtrack that enhances the movie’s atmosphere and emotional impact. Here are some notable tracks:
You can find the complete soundtrack on Amazon Music and Apple Music.
🤨 FAQ
‘Elsewhere’ is a crime drama and thriller from 2009 about a teenage girl in a small Indiana town who disappears after using online dating sites to try and escape her life. Her best friend is the only one who takes her disappearance seriously and begins an investigation, uncovering dark secrets about the town and its residents.
The main cast of ‘Elsewhere’ (2009) includes Anna Kendrick as Sarah, Tania Raymonde as Jillian, Jon Gries as Mr. Tod, Paul Wesley as Billy, and Chuck Carter as Jasper. It’s notable for featuring Anna Kendrick and Paul Wesley early in their careers.
While ‘Elsewhere’ contains elements of suspense and danger, it is primarily categorized as a crime drama and thriller, rather than a horror film. Reviews note it has a few thrills but lacks gore or typical horror elements, focusing more on the mystery and psychological aspects.
‘Elsewhere’ (2009) may be available for digital rental or purchase on platforms like Amazon Prime Video, Apple TV, Vudu, Google Play, and YouTube Movies. Check these services for current availability in your location.
According to production details, the movie ‘Elsewhere’ (2009) was filmed on location in Goshen, Indiana, which is also the setting for the film’s story. Filming locations included the Goshen Public Library.
🔥 Bonus Content
Are Emily and Victoria Sisters? How did Emily Die? The Corpse Bride Theory – The Fangirl
Hey, did you ever ponder some of the darker mysteries in Corpse Bride, like the true connection between Emily and Victoria or exactly how Emily met her tragic end? This theory video totally unpacks some fascinating ideas, and honestly, it makes you think about the movie in a whole new way!
✨ Rate
There are no reviews yet. Be the first one to write one.