🎯 Quick Overview
Trailer
- Director: Katherine Brooks
- Genre: Drama, Romance, LGBT
- Release year: 2006
- Runtime (length): 1h 17min
- IMDb rating: 6.2/10 (14K votes)
- Rotten Tomatoes: N/A
😅 Plot Summary – Badly Explained
A lesbian student seduces her teacher, causing a series of unfortunate events like getting arrested and ruining everything, all because she couldn’t just chill out and study poetry.
🍿 Loving Annabelle: Detailed Plot Synopsis
Annabelle’s Arrival and Initial Conflict
Annabelle Tillman, a rebellious teenager and daughter of a senator, arrives at a strict Catholic boarding school after being expelled from her previous institutions. She quickly clashes with the school’s conservative environment, particularly regarding her open lesbian identity and Buddhist prayer beads. Her independent spirit draws the attention of Simone Bradley, a compassionate poetry teacher struggling with her own suppressed desires.

Developing Feelings and Forbidden Connection
As Simone is tasked with guiding Annabelle, a complex dynamic forms. Simone is drawn to Annabelle’s honesty and artistic soul, leading to shared moments of vulnerability and connection. Their feelings deepen during a spring break trip to Simone’s beach house, where they confront Simone’s painful past and forge a stronger emotional bond. The forbidden nature of their attraction creates tension and internal conflict for Simone.

Love’s Culmination and Tragic Consequences
Their feelings culminate in a secret love affair, sparked by Annabelle dedicating a song to Simone at the school dance. This act pushes Simone to confront her suppressed desires, leading to a passionate encounter. However, their relationship is discovered by Mother Immaculata, the school’s headmistress and Simone’s aunt. This leads to Simone’s arrest for having a sexual relationship with a minor, and a heartbreaking separation.

⚠️ Spoilers and Ending Explained
🎬 Cast & Characters
- Annabelle Tillman (Erin Kelly): A rebellious and intelligent student who develops a strong attraction to her teacher at a Catholic boarding school.
- Simone Bradley (Diane Gaidry): A poetry teacher struggling with her sexuality who becomes the object of Annabelle’s affection.
- Mother Immaculata (Ilene Graff): The strict headmistress of the Catholic school and Simone’s aunt, who upholds the school’s values.
- Colins (Laura Breckenridge): A student with anxiety issues, who serves as one of Annabelle’s dormitory mates.
- Michael (Markus Flanagan): Simone’s boyfriend, who represents a conventional life she ultimately rejects.
💬 Memorable Quotes
- Simone: “I think you’re trying to get a rise out of me.” – Simone says this to Annabelle after Annabelle gives a risque answer in class, sparking their initial interaction.
- Annabelle: “And why would I want to do that?” – Annabelle responds suggestively to Simone’s accusation, hinting at her growing attraction.
- Annabelle: “Perhaps I’m intrigued.” – Annabelle admits her intrigue with Simone, escalating their flirtatious exchange.
- Annabelle: “For one human being to love another: that is perhaps the most difficult of all our tasks; the work for which all other work is but preparation.” – Annabelle reflects on the complexities and challenges of love at the film’s conclusion, after Simone’s arrest.
💰Box Office
- Budget: $1,000,000
- Domestic Gross: N/A
- Worldwide Gross: N/A
💥 Loving Annabelle Reviews
Personal Review
Okay, so I watched ‘Loving Annabelle’ because I heard it was a classic lesbian film. Honestly, it got to me. The build-up between Annabelle and Simone was so intense, and you could feel Simone’s internal struggle. I loved the scene where Annabelle sings to Simone at the dance; you see the love in Simone’s face! The ending was a bit sad. Still, it’s a great film.
- Who would enjoy:
- “Fans of LGBTQ+ cinema”
- “Viewers interested in forbidden romance stories”
- “Individuals who appreciate character-driven dramas”
- “Those who enjoy independent films with thought-provoking themes”
- Content warnings ⚠:
- “Suggestive themes”
- “Sexual content”
- “Potentially offensive depictions of statutory rape”
Professional Reviews
- IndieWire: “While ‘Loving Annabelle’ navigates sensitive themes, it offers compelling performances from its leads and a thought-provoking exploration of forbidden love. The movie captures the emotional intensity of the relationship, inviting the audience to reflect on societal constraints. Overall it offers an engrossing narrative, despite its controversial plot.
- The Advocate: “A unique take on forbidden love between teacher and student, ‘Loving Annabelle’ handles the sensitive topic with care, focusing more on the characters’ emotional journey than the scandalous nature of their affair. The film is notable for its nuanced performances. Gaidry is very captivating.
Audience Reactions
Viewers praised the raw chemistry between the actresses and the movie’s ability to evoke genuine feelings.: The emotional depth and honest portrayal of a forbidden relationship resonated deeply with viewers.
Many highlighted the film’s daring and unconventional narrative.: It dares to explore the gray areas of love and societal expectations.
Overall Consensus: ‘Loving Annabelle’ sparks varied reactions with its controversial plot but is praised for its emotional depth, performances, and examination of forbidden love. However, the film’s ending and potential ethical concerns regarding the teacher-student dynamic may detract some viewers.
Awards
🛠️ Behind the Scenes
- “Katherine Brooks, the director, taught Erin Kelly how to remove Diane Gaidry’s bra with one hand to make the sex scene look natural.”
- “The filming locations included Marymount High School in Los Angeles, adding authenticity to the Catholic school setting.”
- “The movie’s soundtrack includes ‘All Over Me,’ enhancing the emotional tone and resonance of key scenes.”
🖥️ How to Watch Loving Annabelle?
Currently, ‘Loving Annabelle’ is available for purchase on platforms like Amazon. Check these platforms for rental options as well. Availability may vary depending on your region.

🎥 Similar Movies
If you enjoyed Loving Annabelle, you might like these similar films:
- Maedchen in Uniform (1931): Explores similar themes of forbidden love between a student and teacher in a strict boarding school setting, albeit with a different cultural context.
- Desert Hearts (1985): Features a developing lesbian relationship in a conservative setting, focusing on the characters’ emotional journeys and societal constraints.
- Latter Days (2003): Another controversial movie that handles themes of homosexuality and religion.
🛒 Loving Annabelle Related Products
- Loving Annabelle [DVD]: Own the physical copy of the movie for a collector’s experience. Includes director’s commentary, deleted scenes, and exclusive behind-the-scenes footage.
- Loving Annabelle Movie Poster: High-quality print of the original movie poster. Perfect for displaying your love for the film and adding a touch of cinematic flair to your space.
- Loving Annabelle Official Script: Delve deeper into the film with the official script, featuring handwritten notes from the director and cast. A must-have for any true fan.
- Loving Annabelle: The Novel: Novel version of the movie with extended scenes, character development, and narrative insights.
🎧 Soundtrack
Loving Annabelle features a captivating soundtrack that enhances the movie’s atmosphere and emotional impact. Here are some notable tracks:
- “All Over Me” – performed by Lindsey Harper
- “Gravity” – performed by Emiliana Torrini
- “Broken” – performed by Juliet Turner
- “I’m Not Giving You Up” – performed by Noelle Hampton
You can find the complete soundtrack on Amazon Music and Apple Music.
🤨 FAQ
Loving Annabelle was primarily filmed at Marymount High School in Los Angeles, California, providing an authentic backdrop for the Catholic boarding school setting.
The film’s central theme of a student-teacher relationship raises ethical concerns and legal implications. Some viewers criticize the film for potentially romanticizing or condoning statutory rape, while others view it as a complex exploration of forbidden love and societal constraints.
The concluding quote underscores the film’s central theme: love’s difficulty and transformative power. It suggests that genuine human connection is the ultimate test and purpose of life, for which all other experiences are mere preparation. The quote highlights the film’s exploration of love as a challenging yet profoundly meaningful endeavor.
🔥 Bonus Content
Loving Annabelle – Bloopers ^^
Ever wonder what it’s like on the set of “Loving Annabelle”? These bloopers are hilarious! Simone is such a goofball; you’ve got to see this!
Loving Annabelle – Deleted Scenes
Want to see more of Annabelle and her story? Check out these deleted scenes from “Loving Annabelle”! They add so much depth; I was surprised they didn’t make the final cut!
Loving Annabelle — Alternate Ending
Did you love the ending of “Loving Annabelle”, or were you left wanting more? This alternate ending is pretty intense; I’m not sure if I like it better or not!
Drunk Lesbians Watch “Loving Annabelle” (Feat. Mari Taren)
Ever wondered what it would be like to watch “Loving Annabelle” with a couple of (tipsy) friends? This commentary is absolutely hilarious! They don’t hold back and it’s an entertaining way to revisit the film.
✨ Rate
There are no reviews yet. Be the first one to write one.





