The Molly Maguires Synopsis & Review: Plot Summary

🎯 Quick Overview

😅 Plot Summary – Badly Explained

An undercover cop pretends to be an Irish coal miner to rat out his angry co-workers who are tired of getting paid pennies and blowing stuff up.

🍿 The Molly Maguires: Detailed Plot Synopsis

Life in the 1870s Pennsylvania Coal Mines

Set in 1876 Pennsylvania, the film depicts the brutal realities of life for Irish immigrant coal miners. Working conditions are harsh, dangerous, and back-breaking, with inadequate safety measures and exploitative wages. The miners face constant risks and struggle to survive, often receiving only pennies after deductions for tools and supplies. This oppressive environment breeds deep resentment against the mining company owners and officials.

The Rise of the Molly Maguires

In response to the dire conditions and lack of recourse through conventional means, a secret society known as the Molly Maguires emerges among the Irish miners. Drawing on a history from Ireland, this group resorts to sabotage, intimidation, and violence to fight the oppressive company and its agents. Led by the charismatic Jack Kehoe, the Molly Maguires seek to force the company to improve conditions and pay, though their methods are often extreme.

An Undercover Detective Arrives

Concerned by the escalating attacks, the powerful mining company hires the Pinkerton Detective Agency to infiltrate and dismantle the Molly Maguires. Detective James McParlan, also an Irish immigrant, is sent undercover under the alias ‘James McKenna’ to pose as a miner seeking work. McParlan’s mission is to gain the trust of the Molly Maguires, identify their leaders, and gather evidence to bring them to justice. He must navigate the dangerous world of the mines and the suspicions of the locals.

Infiltration and Shifting Loyalties

Working alongside the miners, McParlan experiences firsthand the brutal conditions and the miners’ desperation. He gradually earns the trust of Jack Kehoe and is inducted into the secret society. As he becomes more deeply embedded, McParlan witnesses both the injustices faced by the miners and the violent acts committed by the Molly Maguires. This puts him in a difficult position, forcing him to confront his own conscience and the true cost of his mission.

⚠️ Spoilers and Ending Explained

🎬 Cast & Characters

• Detective James McParlan (Richard Harris): An undercover Pinkerton detective sent to infiltrate the violent secret society of Irish immigrant miners.
• Jack Kehoe (Sean Connery): The charismatic and resolute leader of the Molly Maguires who employs sabotage and murder to combat harsh mining conditions.
• Miss Mary Raines (Samantha Eggar): The kind landlady who provides lodging for McParlan and becomes a romantic interest, representing the community’s perspective.
• Davies (Frank Finlay): The stern police captain who acts as McParlan’s handler, focusing on bringing the Molly Maguires to justice by any means.
• Dougherty (Anthony Zerbe): A loyal member of the Molly Maguires who participates in their violent actions and is close to Kehoe.

💬 Memorable Quotes

• Detective James McParlan: “Well, I’m a miner now. I’ll be traveling in that direction anyway, just out of habit.” – Said in a darkly humorous response to Mary Raines’ warning that joining the Molly Maguires would lead him to hell, reflecting his bleak perspective on his situation.
• Detective James McParlan: “You buy decency and respectability like you buy a loaf of bread.” – Stated to Mary Raines, explaining his cynical and pragmatic view that morality is a luxury that can only be afforded by those with means.
• Jack Kehoe: “There’s no punishment short of hell can redeem your treachery.” – Delivered to McParlan during their final, tense conversation in Kehoe’s prison cell before his execution, conveying his profound condemnation of McParlan’s betrayal.
• Detective James McParlan: “See you in hell.” – McParlan’s chilling final words to Kehoe, accepting the gravity of his actions and the potential consequences for his soul.

💰Box Office

• Budget: $11,000,000
• Domestic Gross: $2,000,000
• Worldwide Gross: Not available

💥 The Molly Maguires Reviews

Personal Review

Wow, this movie felt like a punch to the gut in the best way. I went into it not knowing much about the Molly Maguires, but the film just pulls you right into that incredibly tough world of 1870s coal mining. The grit and grime felt so real, thanks to the amazing cinematography. And the acting! Seeing Sean Connery and Richard Harris square off was pure gold. Their scenes together crackled with tension and layered emotion. It’s definitely not a feel-good movie – the ending left me thinking for a long time. But it’s a powerful, moving historical drama that really makes you appreciate the struggles people went through to fight for fair treatment. Totally worth watching if you want something with depth.

• Who would enjoy:
  • “Fans of historical dramas and period pieces”
  • “Viewers interested in labor history and social justice themes”
  • “Admirers of Sean Connery and Richard Harris’ work”
  • “Those who appreciate gritty, realistic portrayals of difficult historical periods”
• Content warnings ⚠:
  • “Depicts harsh and dangerous working conditions”
  • “Features violence and murder related to conflict and sabotage”
  • “Downbeat and tragic narrative arc”
  • “Some dialogue may be challenging to understand due to period accents”

Professional Reviews

• Synthesized from User Reviews: “Martin Ritt’s historical drama delves into the harsh realities of 1876 Pennsylvania coal country. While the pacing is deliberate, the atmosphere is palpable, drawing you into the gritty world of the miners. Sean Connery delivers a powerful, understated performance as the leader of the Molly Maguires, matched by Richard Harris’s complex portrayal of the conflicted detective. James Wong Howe’s cinematography paints a bleak yet striking picture of the landscape and the difficult lives lived there. It’s a thought-provoking look at early labor struggles, carried by strong performances.
• Synthesized from User Reviews: “This film is an unjustly overlooked gem exploring a fascinating, often ignored part of American history. The period detail is magnificent, making the mining town feel incredibly authentic. Harris shines as the detective wrestling with his loyalties, and Connery brings gravitas to the rebel leader. Their dynamic is the heart of the film. While it’s not always an easy watch, given the bleak subject matter, it’s a compelling and worthwhile experience that stays with you.

Audience Reactions

Many viewers were struck by the film’s authentic recreation of the grim 19th-century mining environment.: The standout performances by Sean Connery and Richard Harris are frequently praised, particularly their intense scenes together. The film’s historical accuracy (or inspiration) and atmospheric cinematography are also common points of positive feedback, despite its depressing subject matter and slow pace.

Overall Consensus: A gritty, atmospheric historical drama praised for its strong acting and authentic portrayal of miner struggles, though its slow pace and bleak ending divided some viewers.

Awards

🛠️ Behind the Scenes

• “Much of the movie was filmed in Eckley, Pennsylvania, an actual 19th-century coal mining town. Paramount Pictures saved the town from being demolished for strip mining by filming there; the land was later donated to the Pennsylvania Historical and Museum Commission and the town is now a museum, with some movie structures still standing.”
• “The film was a significant box office failure upon release, earning back only a little over 10% of its estimated $11 million budget, which was a large sum for 1970.”
• “Director Martin Ritt originally wanted to shoot the film in black and white to create a starker mood, but the studio insisted on color photography.”
• “Sean Connery’s character, Jack Kehoe, despite being a lead, does not have his first speaking line until approximately 40 minutes into the movie.”
• “In reality, the historical Jack Kehoe was not a coal miner, but a saloon owner, which differs from his portrayal in the film.”

🖥️ How to Watch The Molly Maguires?

Discover where to watch the historical drama ‘The Molly Maguires’ (1970). This film is often available for rent or purchase on major digital platforms, including Amazon Prime Video. Check your preferred streaming services and digital retailers for current availability.

🎥 Similar Movies

If you enjoyed The Molly Maguires, you might like these similar films:

• Matewan (1987): A direct comparison exploring similar themes of labor struggles, corporate oppression, and violent conflict in a coal mining town, also based on historical events.
• On the Waterfront (1954): Examines issues of union corruption, loyalty, and the moral weight of testifying against a powerful, violent organization, paralleling McParlan’s dilemma.
• Heaven’s Gate (1980): A visually ambitious, large-budget historical drama from the same era that also explores violent conflict between powerful elites and immigrant communities in the late 19th century, sharing themes of class struggle and societal injustice.
• Dark Waters (2019): A modern film based on a true story about a lawyer’s fight against a large corporation over environmental damage affecting a community, reflecting the theme of battling systemic corporate power and corruption.
• Emperor of the North (1973): A gritty cult classic depicting the brutal struggle between an authoritative railroad conductor and a defiant hobo during the Depression, resonating with the theme of the working class fighting against an oppressive system.

🛒 The Molly Maguires Related Products

• The Molly Maguires (Blu-ray): Own the acclaimed historical drama on high-definition Blu-ray, featuring stunning cinematography that captures the film’s atmospheric period detail.
• The Molly Maguires: The Story of the Great Labor War in the Anthracite Coal Fields of Pennsylvania: Dive deeper into the true history that inspired the movie with this comprehensive book, exploring the events, people, and broader context of the Molly Maguires.
• Eckley Miners’ Village Museum Souvenir Guide: A guide to the actual historic town in Pennsylvania where much of the film was shot, now a living history museum preserving the coal mining era.
• Anthracite Coal Region: A History of Mining, Culture, and Struggle: An in-depth look at the history, culture, and challenges of the Pennsylvania coal region, providing rich context for the film’s setting and themes.

🎧 Soundtrack

The Molly Maguires features a captivating soundtrack that enhances the movie’s atmosphere and emotional impact. Here are some notable tracks:

• “Eileen Aroon” – performed by Traditional Irish Song
• “The Molly Maguires (Original Motion Picture Score)” – performed by Henry Mancini

You can find the complete soundtrack on Amazon Music and Apple Music.

🤨 FAQ

🔥 Bonus Content

Violence in Coal Mining in the 1870s

Ever wonder about the real history that kicked off this intense movie? This quick video dives into the actual violence in coal mining back in the 1870s that set the stage for the story you just watched – it really makes you appreciate the film’s themes even more.

✨ Rate