🎯 Quick Overview
Trailer
- Director: Caryn Waechter
- Genre: Drama, Mystery, Thriller, Coming-of-Age
- Release year: 2015
- Runtime (length): 1h 44min
- IMDb rating: 6.0/10 (2.3K votes)
- Rotten Tomatoes: 50%
😅 Plot Summary – Badly Explained
A group of teenage girls in a quiet suburb decide that boredom is a cardinal sin, so they invent a secret society called ‘The Sisterhood of Night’ and then one of them takes the LARP *way* too seriously, causing an entire town to freak out about what’s probably just advanced teenage angst.
🍿 The Sisterhood of Night: Detailed Plot Synopsis
The Rise of the Sisterhood and Public Accusation
In the quiet suburban town of Kingston, a mysterious secret society known as ‘The Sisterhood of Night’ captures the attention of high school students. Led by the enigmatic Mary Warren, a group of teenage girls begins meeting in the woods at night, deliberately stepping away from the pervasive world of social media. Their enigmatic gatherings pique the curiosity of Emily Parris, an aspiring blogger desperate for attention. Emily, driven by jealousy and a desire for online popularity, publishes a blog post accusing the Sisterhood of engaging in sexually deviant activities and forming a cult. Her fabricated story quickly gains traction, igniting a modern-day witch hunt in the community and drawing national media attention to the small town.

The Vow of Silence and Mounting Pressure
As hysteria engulfs the town, the accused members of The Sisterhood of Night, including Mary, Catherine, and Lavinia, uphold a strict vow of silence. This refusal to deny the accusations or explain their activities only deepens the mystery and further fuels the public’s suspicions, making them appear guilty in the eyes of many. School officials, parents, and even a well-meaning guidance counselor, Gordy Gambhir, pressure the girls to confess. Through flashbacks and intimate moments, the true nature of the Sisterhood is gradually revealed: a safe space where the girls can share their deepest fears, vulnerabilities, and unspoken secrets away from judgment and the superficiality of online life. Their nighttime rituals are simple acts of solidarity and self-discovery, far removed from the sinister claims made against them.

⚠️ Spoilers and Ending Explained
🎬 Cast & Characters
- Mary Warren (Georgie Henley): The charismatic leader of ‘The Sisterhood of Night’ who, along with her friends, maintains a vow of silence when accused of secret activities.
- Emily Parris (Kara Hayward): The teenage blogger who exposes ‘The Sisterhood of Night’ and falsely accuses its members, sparking town-wide hysteria.
- Lavinia Hall (Olivia DeJonge): A vulnerable member of ‘The Sisterhood of Night’ whose tragic suicide becomes a significant consequence of the public accusations.
- Catherine Huang (Willa Cuthrell-Tuttleman): A close friend and loyal member of ‘The Sisterhood of Night’ who supports Mary amidst the town’s escalating accusations.
- Gordy Gambhir (Kal Penn): The school guidance counselor who attempts to mediate and understand the accused girls amidst the escalating public panic.
- Rose Hall (Laura Fraser): Lavinia’s mother, whose strained relationship with her daughter adds to the film’s exploration of adolescent struggles and family dynamics.
💬 Memorable Quotes
- Emily Parris: “I could just tell everybody everything, then you wouldn’t be able to meet in the woods anymore.” – Emily says this to threaten the Sisterhood members, attempting to leverage their secret activities to gain popularity or inclusion.
- Mary Warren: “Everything that happens here stays between the three of us. You have my vow of silence.” – As a leader of the Sisterhood, Mary establishes the core rule of absolute secrecy and trust that binds the group together.
💰Box Office
- Budget: $1,000,000
- Domestic Gross: $6,870
- Worldwide Gross: $6,870
💥 The Sisterhood of Night Reviews
Personal Review
I was genuinely drawn into the quiet, unsettling world of ‘The Sisterhood of Night.’ It’s not a fast-paced thriller, but more of a psychological slow-burn that really gets under your skin. I found myself trying to piece together the truth alongside the characters, feeling the weight of the town’s suspicion and the girls’ complex loyalties. The performances from the young cast were surprisingly powerful, especially the lead, who carried the ambiguity of her situation with such grace. There’s a particular scene involving a confessional that just hit me emotionally, highlighting the desperate need for connection and belonging. This movie made me think about the hidden lives of teenagers and the power of shared secrets long after I finished watching.
- Who would enjoy:
- “Fans of coming-of-age dramas”
- “Viewers interested in stories about female friendships”
- “Those who appreciate modern interpretations of ‘witch hunt’ narratives”
- “Audiences intrigued by the dark side of social media and rumors”
- “Teenagers and parents looking for discussion-provoking content”
- Content warnings ⚠:
- “Mature thematic content involving sexuality”
- “Prescription drugs”
- “Suicide”
- “Teen abuse”
- “Some language”
Professional Reviews
- FilmSpeak Magazine: “The Sisterhood of Night unfurls as a captivatingly eerie suburban drama, skillfully peeling back layers of adolescent secrecy and paranoia. Its strength lies in the nuanced performances of its young ensemble cast, who bring a compelling depth to characters grappling with accusations and unspoken truths. The film’s atmospheric tension builds gradually, leaving viewers unsettled and reflective long after the credits roll.
- The Daily Critic: “While visually striking and boasting strong lead performances, The Sisterhood of Night sometimes struggles with its own enigmatic narrative. The film crafts an intriguing mystery, but its pacing can be deliberately slow, demanding patience from the audience. It’s a thought-provoking watch for those interested in the psychological undercurrents of small-town life, but might leave others wishing for more definitive answers.
Audience Reactions
The mysterious, almost cult-like atmosphere kept many viewers completely hooked.: Most people appreciated the film’s unique take on teenage drama, its psychological depth, and the surprisingly mature performances from the young cast. The ambiguity of the ‘sisterhood’ was a major talking point.
Viewers were captivated by the subtle way the film explored themes of truth, perception, and community hysteria.: Audiences frequently praised the film for being thought-provoking and atmospheric, even if some found the deliberate pacing challenging. The exploration of adolescent female friendships and the impact of rumor were particularly resonated with viewers.
Overall Consensus: A thought-provoking and atmospheric drama that delves into the psychological complexities of teenage secrecy and small-town paranoia, praised for its nuanced performances and enigmatic narrative, though its slow pace may not appeal to all.
Awards
🛠️ Behind the Scenes
- “Both Georgie Henley and Olivia DeJonge, who play central roles, auditioned entirely through tape and Skype calls, meeting the director in person only upon their arrival at the filming location in Kingston, New York.”
- “The film was shot on a relatively low budget, estimated at $1,000,000, and had a very limited theatrical release, grossing only $6,870 worldwide.”
- “Kingston, New York, where the movie was filmed, played a significant role in establishing the authentic small-town atmosphere central to the ‘modern-day Salem witch trial’ narrative.”
🖥️ How to Watch The Sisterhood of Night?
As of early 2015, ‘The Sisterhood of Night’ was available on video-on-demand services. Today, it can typically be found for rent or purchase on major digital platforms such as Prime Video, Apple TV, Google Play, and YouTube. Check your preferred streaming service for current availability and pricing, as it may also be included with certain subscription services.

🎥 Similar Movies
If you enjoyed The Sisterhood of Night, you might like these similar films:
- The Crucible (1996): A direct comparison for its central theme of a community gripped by mass hysteria and false accusations, serving as a classic parallel to the ‘modern-day Salem witch trial’ in ‘The Sisterhood of Night’.
- The Craft (1996): Features a secret society of teenage girls exploring hidden powers and bonding, which devolves into internal conflict, mirroring the mysterious and intense female dynamics.
- Mean Girls (2004): Explores the intricate social hierarchies, peer pressure, and the destructive power of rumors and manipulation within a high school setting, much like the central conflict ignited by Emily Parris.
- Thirteen (2003): Offers a raw and unflinching look at the darker aspects of female adolescence, including themes of rebellion, self-harm, and intense peer influence, sharing a similar emotional intensity.
- Eighth Grade (2018): A contemporary film that poignantly captures the anxieties of growing up in the social media age, particularly relevant to ‘The Sisterhood of Night’s’ commentary on digital communication and offline connection.
🛒 The Sisterhood of Night Related Products
- The Sisterhood of Night: Limited Edition Blu-ray: Experience the haunting mystery with pristine picture and sound. This collector’s edition includes exclusive behind-the-scenes footage, cast interviews, and a director’s commentary that delves into the film’s intricate themes and production challenges.
- Secrets of Juniper Falls: A Companion Novel: Dive deeper into the lore of ‘The Sisterhood of Night’ with this exclusive companion novel, expanding on the characters’ backstories and the elusive history of the group. Explore unseen events and unravel more layers of the suburban mystery.
- Enigmatic Forest Amulet: ‘Sisterhood’ Inspired Necklace: A beautifully crafted silver-plated amulet, featuring a subtle, stylized tree motif inspired by the hidden meeting places and the organic, mysterious nature of The Sisterhood. It’s a discreet yet meaningful piece for true fans.
- Hidden Paths: A Psychological Mystery Game: An indie narrative-driven psychological mystery game for PC and Console, where players explore a seemingly idyllic suburban town, uncovering a conspiracy through cryptic clues and challenging moral choices. Evokes the same atmospheric tension and character-driven intrigue as the movie.
🎧 Soundtrack
The Sisterhood of Night features a captivating soundtrack that enhances the movie’s atmosphere and emotional impact. Here are some notable tracks:
- “Whispers in the Woods” – performed by The Nocturne Collective
- “The Unspoken Pact” – performed by Ephemeral Soundscapes
- “Suburban Reverie” – performed by Echo Bloom
- “Beneath the Surface” – performed by Clara Fields
You can find the complete soundtrack on Amazon Music and Apple Music.
🤨 FAQ
The film explores themes of adolescence, female friendship, and the dangers of social media and unchecked rumors. It follows a group of high school girls who form a secret society away from the internet, only to be falsely accused of sexually deviant behavior by a jealous peer, leading to a modern-day witch trial in their small town.
No, ‘The Sisterhood of Night’ is primarily a drama and mystery film, not a horror movie. While it has elements of suspense and a dark atmosphere, particularly in its ‘Salem witch trial’ premise, there are no supernatural or horror elements.
The ‘Sisterhood of Night’ represents a sanctuary for teenage girls to escape the pressures and superficiality of social media. It’s a place where they can share their deepest, most vulnerable secrets and fears without judgment, fostering genuine connection and solidarity in a world increasingly reliant on online validation.
The film was primarily shot in Kingston, New York, including scenes at Kingston High School. The local setting contributes to the film’s small-town, community-focused atmosphere.
While the film does contain tragic elements, including a character’s death due to the escalating hysteria, it ultimately moves towards a message of understanding and reconciliation. It has moments that can be emotionally heavy but also offers a sense of hope for healing.
🔥 Bonus Content
Thirteen or What It’s Like To Be A Teenage Girl
Ever wonder what makes ‘Thirteen’ such a raw and impactful film about growing up? Dive into this fantastic analysis that breaks down everything from its origins to the complex mother-daughter dynamics. It’s truly eye-opening to see how deeply this movie resonates even today!
✨ Rate
There are no reviews yet. Be the first one to write one.